The Joel Bieber Firm

Call 1-800-451-6393

The Evidence Sniffer!

Friday, August 28th, 2015

A Labrador Retriever named Bear  (which is more relaxing than a bear named Labrador) was enlisted to “sniff out” a computer thumb drive in the home of Jared Fogle. The thumb drive played a key role in  child pornography charges being filed against the former Subway spokesman. (NBC News) It was evidence that humans had failed to find during a  July search of Fogle’s house.

The “talent” that was in search of the Fogle evidence acquired this special skill because a chemist named Jack Hubball tested flash drives, circuit boards and other electronic components, and determined that there was a common chemical that was found in all of them. Then, Hubball trained three dogs to recognize that scent; Much the way that other dogs can pick up the scent of a fugitive, or cocaine stashed in a car compartment or piece of luggage.

“Digital Detective” Bear can smell the components of electronic media. It doesn’t matter if it’s stuck in a drawer, as small as a micro-card the size of a fingernail. The hope is that dogs will also be able to be trained in weapons of terror. The new war on crime with the assistance of man’s best friend.

And for our weekend pic…


Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

Comments (0)

What Do You Think?

Making it Politics

Wednesday, August 26th, 2015

“Did you see the news?” That was repeated among us yesterday after two journalists were shot here in Virginia. When I initially pulled up the story online, I saw a darkened image of the supposed shooter. Later I learned his identity.  At no time did I hear anyone here at the office express anything politically about the shooting.  Instead, I repeatedly heard how awful it was.

Later I read more on the shooting and the unfolding events. Then, I started to see politicians coming out of the woodwork to express their sympathies. Then, I saw several take the opportunity to express the need for gun control.

Based on the minimal information that I know about the events, I suppose that someone could express an opinion about gun control, depression, discrimination lawsuits or even what can be easily uploaded to social media.

I wonder if there is a politician that can stop themselves from seizing the opportunity to express immediate opinion. Instead, maybe they could just remember humanity. Everyone around me just felt terrible about what had happened. No one was talking about political issues. It was all about why someone would be so cruel.

Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

Categories : Uncategorized
Comments (0)

What Do You Think?

Judge Uses Internet

Wednesday, August 26th, 2015

At the beginning of each trial, judges usually instruct jurors that they are to base their decision on the evidence and nothing else. In our openings, we sometimes refer to information that is not part of the introduced evidence as ”outside the box”.

Recently 7th Circuit Appeals Judge Richard Posner decided to do some of his own outside research, and another judge took him to task. in the same opinion. Initially, the case revolved around an Indiana inmate who claimed that prison officials had confiscated his Zantac that he took for his acid reflux.

As a result, he was unable to take the pills with his meals, because he had to wait for the  nurse to dispense them. So, he filed suit against prison officials without the help of a lawyer. During the suit, his  Zantac prescription lapsed and prison officials ignored his request for a new prescription. They indicated that he could just purchase it offsite, over the counter.

A month later, a prison physician renewed the prescription, but the pills were still dispensed by a nurse, 5.5 to 6.5 hours before mealtime, instead of with his meals. That schedule does not work for the medication to alleviate his condition.

The inmates lawsuit was dismissed and he appealed it.  Factually, he had been denied appointed counsel, access to a medical expert, and couldn’t afford to pay for any help. He appealed!

When it got to the 7th District Appellate Court, Judge Posner decided to go to the Internet and do his own research.  He visited several websites for information on acid reflux and and on the medication  Zantac. He wanted to learn when the drug should be taken. He admitted that the websites  he visited included the Mayo Clinic, WebMD, Healthline, the National Institutes of Health, the Physicians’ Desk Reference, and Wikipedia. He also  wanted to know about the prison doctor who wrote the new prescription to be dispensed by the nurse so he visited healthgrades  on that doctor, a defendant who also served as his own expert witness in the case.

It obviously fired up Judge Posner because he wrote in his opinion (for some sleepy-time reading, Judge Posner’s opinion is attached here):

Shall the unreliability of the unalloyed adversary process in a case of such dramatic inequality of resources and capabilities of the parties as this case be an unalterable bar to justice?” It is heartless to make a fetish of adversary procedure if by doing so feeble evidence is credited because the opponent has no practical access to offsetting evidence.”

Basically, the Judge was saying that the system should not be allowed to bully this prison inmate who just wanted to take his medication. He came to that conclusion by doing his own research to determine when it should have been correctly taken.

However, judges know that jurors are not supposed to consider outside information… like going to the Internet and doing their own research. As a result of Posner’s actions, another Judge took him to task in both a concurring and dissenting opinion; meaning that he agreed with the finding but disagreed with Posner’s research.

Judge Hamilton said about Posner’s research that it  “turns the court from a neutral decision-maker into an advocate for one side” and raises unanswered questions. “When are district judges supposed to carry out this independent factual research?” Hamilton continues. “How much is enough? What standards of reliability should apply to the results?”

Judge Ilana Diamond Rovner also wrote that the case had “morphed into a debate” about Internet research. In Rovner’s view, deciding the correct result on appeal didn’t require anything outside the record.

In the end, the inmate won and a larger victory given to future inmates. It also opens the debate on whether judges can do their own research outside of the existing record. Things that make you go Hmmm!

And for pic o’ day, here’s one that was sent from Jessica:


Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

What Do You Think?

Law and Blue’s Clues

Monday, August 24th, 2015

Blue’s Clues is a show that is credited with helping to build the popularity of Nickelodeon Television.  The show came out in the mid-nineties. It follows an animated blue-spotted dog named Blue, who gives clues to viewers as a learning tool. According to Wikipedia, a study of the show found that children between the ages of six and thirty six months benefited in vocabulary and communication. Even young children enjoyed solving puzzles!

I was reminded of that show when I read about police solving crimes in the Hampton Roads area. Two stories in Pilot Online tell these clue stories.

First was the story of the selfie that solved the crime.    A man called the police after two men robbed him of money… when he was trying to buy marijuana from them.  The two men handed him a  backpack. When he opened it, they pushed him to the ground and took his money.

The backpack didn’t contain marijuana, the man later told police – it contained socks. And insult to injury for him… he didn’t even get to keep the socks; the two men even grabbed the backpack and ran.

After he called the police, they searched the area and found a cellphone in a nearby yard. The phone contained a photo of a shirtless selfie. Police showed it to the man who was robbed… who identified the selfie as one of his robbers. The case of the careless selfie!

The second case  involves a Mercedes that was vandalized with eggs. However, police found a clue under the seat… a receipt for eggs.

The receipt had details of the  purchase of a dozen eggs and syrup from a nearby Wal-Mart. It also showed the credit card and transaction numbers. Store employees were able to pull up the video of the man who made the egg purchase. The case of the cracked egg clues!

And for pic o’ day… Is this a clue?


Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

Comments (0)

What Do You Think?

Power of Name Lawsuit

Sunday, August 23rd, 2015

Proverbs 22:1 says that, “a good name is rather to be chosen than great wealth”. A recent lawsuit reminded us that a good name creates great wealth.

Recently I learned that Lebron James has over 23 million followers on twitter  that companies pay him 140K per sponsored tweet. (awful announcing) The value of his name! Kind of nice to be able to send out a 140 character message that says something like I like to use Clorox on my shirt collars, for some quick money from a quick cell phone tweet.

I can tweet out wisdom in the form of Jedi Master Yoda’s words,  ”Difficult to see.  Always in motion is the future.” and no one pays me… much attention!

When someone other than Michael Jordan is using his name in an advertisement, then it leads to a lawsuit to determine damages. A Dominick’s grocery story chain ran a newspaper ad that congratulated Jordan on his induction in the hall of fame. I decided to attach a copy of the ad to the blog… and the pictures are now all copyrighted, so google the story and image to see it.

At the bottom of the ad, there was a coupon for steaks. That’s what caught the lawyers’ attention. In the end, the unauthorized use of his name ended in a verdict against the grocery story chain in the amount of 8.9 million.

The trial became all about the value of Michael Jordan’s name. It’s not surprising that his name would have great value, ecause advertisers regularly pay him to use his name.

Out of curiosity, I decided to look for an article on celebrity endorsements. Here are the 10 highest paid endorsement deals. (TheRichest) George Clooney has made over 50 million because of a coffee endorsement. It’s probably more of a head-shaker to me that Justin Bieber was paid 12 million to sell nail polish. These endorsement deals are part of the reason that someone like Jordan protects the use of his name.

Really, I only have one final thought on this lawsuit. It seems to me that from reading the news articles, the defense attorneys focused on the wrong defense. Either their client didn’t mean to use his name for commercial purposes, or the Jordan  name was worth less than 10 million. I think that maybe the best defense would have been that true life showed that the Michael Jordan name was not worth 10 million… because it wasn’t worth 10 million to them.

The grocery store chain steakhouse chain that ran the congratulations ad with the coupon is no longer in business. It certainly was not worth 10 million to them!

And for pic o’ day…






Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

What Do You Think?

Wild Politics

Thursday, August 20th, 2015

I’m am out of town on a case, which means blogging on an iPad. That and sometimes drinking coffee that “tastes something like coffee”.

So, for the blog, I thought I would just post some politics. Plus, who can be angry at a candidate named Deez Nuts!   Looks like he is trending up in a recent poll.  I wonder where he stands on Walnut immigration?


Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

Comments (1)

What Do You Think?

Bumper Stickers on the Jury

Tuesday, August 18th, 2015

Several years ago, I was about to begin in North Carolina. Our trial team loaded up for a trial of indefinite length and checked into the only motel in town. We were told at the front desk that a Walmart was coming soon. The manager also said that their phone book was the only one in North Carolina that was always smaller than the year before… because people kept moving away. What can you say to that?

It was Friday afternoon and the trial was to start on Monday. So, we swung by the courthouse to pick up the jury panel list and we got to work. We started driving by the houses for any indication of what kind of juror may live at that house. That included looking at their cars to see the bumper stickers on the back of their bumpers.

I realize now that driving by jurors homes is a bit intrusive. I had only been practicing a couple of years, so I suppose that I made a lot of crazy decisions back then. Of course, I later learned that turning down the offer was also a bad idea, as the verdict came in for less. As the judge said at the beginning of trial, “Counselor, you need to settle this case. Everyone in this county has nothing, and they want everyone else to have nothing”.

The bumper sticker ”viewing” was some idea that I had heard at a seminar. Later, I saw a movie that included that question in jury selection. Apparently that Hollywood movie writer had heard the same idea.

Bumper stickers probably aren’t quite as popular now, but maybe we should come out with a give-away bumper sticker that reads, “I hate bumper stickers”.

With that in mind, I saw these pictures of bumper stickers posted online that were recently seen on the road. What kind of jurors are driving these cars?batman


And finally…


Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

What Do You Think?

Turning 55

Thursday, August 13th, 2015

Monday is my birthday. I turn 55. At first, I thought that I might just type those first two sentences as my blog today, But, I didn’t really know what that meant. I “turn” 55?

I decided to google “turning 55″. There are a lot of  people writing about it. There’s even retirement advice. People are writing about their goals and their dog getting old, and driving and not wearing high heels.

It’s odd that I feel disconnected from it. I don’t even know what to say except that I will smile when I say to my parents, “Can you believe that you have a 55-year-old son?”. My wife won’t be surprised if I play some Madden on PlayStation. Turning 55 won’t change that.

It’s a continuum of time. II Peter 3:8 says that, “with the Lord, one day is like a thousand years and a thousand years as one day”. So at least I have that going for me.

I have no thoughts of retiring. Of course, both my parents still work at the church, so I come by that honestly.

I have heard people say that looking over their life, they wouldn’t change anything. Not sure I would say that.  I guess I’m just not thinking too deeply about it.

I enjoy a good laugh; A Chik-fil-A sandwich with extra pickles; A bit of exercising because of things like that sandwich; A good book; A fresh Hanover tomato.

I remain curious; I enjoy a good story. I still dislike insurance companies, and I’m still not sure who shot JFK.

Ben Franklin said that getting older makes you distrust young doctors and old barbers. I can’t say that even resonates with me, but it does make me laugh.

This doesn’t feel like an arrival. I will have cake because I like cake. But, I’d like to eat cake everyday!

Yes, I wish I could write an epic blog about turning 55. Maybe turning 56 or 60 will cause me to be more reflective. For now, I am just glad to be where I am… right now. And, I plan on being just as glad after my birthday on Monday.

I’ll be back with a blog on Wednesday; But, I suspect that my birthday will have no effect on my random blogging!

And for my birthday pic o’….


Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

Courtroom Sketches

Wednesday, August 12th, 2015

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The person credited with that saying is Margaret Wolfe, who wrote many books under the pseudonym of The Duchess.

Of course,  one person’s trash is another man’s treasure. Yes, I could keep going with this nonsense because one man’s fault is another man’s lesson. See, it can get crazy.

Speaking of crazy and an opinion of appearance, the Internet laughed out loud yesterday when courtroom sketches of Tom Brady hit the public. Here are the sketches from the courtroom artist:







Do you think the Brady family will hire her for some family sketches for the home? I also got a good laugh from USA Today, who compiled some of the best memes from this artist’s rendition from the Courtroom.


Here’s one of the funniest:


Sometimes the news is its own blog!

Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

Categories : Current Affairs, Sports
Comments (1)

Some Court News

Tuesday, August 11th, 2015

Yesterday we learned that the Federal 4th Circuit had denied former Governor Bob McDonnell’s appeal. Not one of the fifteen Judges of the Appeals Court voted to reconsider the original panel’s decision to uphold his conviction. Now, his lawyers say that they are proceeding to the next level… The U.S. Supreme Court.

I had several at the office get that alert on their phones. They would mention it to me and then wonder aloud whether he now had to report to jail. While it’s not something I wish on him, it’s the next logical question. Maybe the Supreme Court will think that there is something novel about this case to hear it.  They won’t be influenced by the lower Court’s decision. The benefit of being a Supreme Court Justice!

That was yesterday’s news. Today, I have my eyes on a court in New York City. Tom Brady, Roger Goodell, and representatives for the NFL Players Association will appear before U.S. District Judge Richard Berman for a settlement conference at 11 a.m. in the Daniel Patrick Moynihan U.S. Courthouse.

I expect that the Judge’s settlement conference will see if there is any possibility for the NFL to reduce the four game suspension of Brady, while the Judge will put Brady and his representatives in another room and see if they are willing to accept some form of suspension in settlement, to forego their appeal.

It’s hard to tell if the Judge will lean on the parties like he would in a civil case settlement conference. There has been suggestion that if Brady acknowledges wrongdoing, that the NFL would be willing to reduce the suspension.

As a Colts fan, I have my definite opinion on this. Thankfully for both of us… I have a word limitation goal on my blog!! I will be interested at the news around lunchtime.

And for pic o’ day…


Please click the Facebook “Share” button below this post to let others know you enjoyed reading it. Thanks!

Comments Comments Off